Pope Leo puts the brake on Church reforms

During a time of rising calls for reform within the Catholic Church, Pope Leo X took decisive steps to maintain traditional Church authority and doctrine, effectively halting early reformist momentum. His papacy (1513–1521) coincided with growing discontent across Europe regarding clerical abuses, indulgence sales, and perceived moral decay within the Church hierarchy. The most prominent challenge to papal authority came in 1517, when German monk Martin Luther published his 95 Theses, condemning the sale of indulgences and other church practices. Rather than engage with these criticisms, Pope Leo X responded with increasing hostility. In 1520, he issued the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which condemned 41 of Luther's propositions and threatened excommunication if he did not recant. This marked a turning point in Church history. By refusing to consider internal reform and doubling down on central authority, Pope Leo inadvertently fueled the very movement he sought to suppress. In January 1521, after Luther refused to recant, Leo excommunicated him—cementing the schism that would become the Protestant Reformation. Critics argue that Pope Leo X’s resistance to reform was driven as much by politics and personal interest as by theology. Known for his extravagant lifestyle and deep ties to the powerful Medici family, Leo viewed reform not only as a threat to Church doctrine, but also to his own influence. Ultimately, Pope Leo X’s efforts to put the brake on reform did not stop change—they accelerated it. His refusal to address legitimate grievances sparked a broader upheaval that reshaped Christianity forever.